Bricks and Mortar

A Clearinghouse on Faith, Development and Nonprofits

Archive for Uncategorized

Reflections of a second year PhD student: Traditional PhD or Hybrid PhD?

I am halfway through the second year of my PhD.  I will be done with my mandatory course work in May will take my comps in May and June. Yikes.  I will complete two more classes after that in order to complete my minor “cognate” and will write my proposal during that time.

I thought I would write a longer post discussing some of the challenges and opportunities in pursuing a hybrid PhD.  As a aside, my PhD program is an intensive hybrid program.  I say this because I wish the program mirrored many of the other hybrid programs.  I venture out to NH once a month for six days.  Residencies are held from September to May.  The student does this for 2 years and take at times 12 credits.  It is a brutal schedule, but the course work gets done.  Many other hybrid programs (I will provide you with a list later on) meet for a several weeks in summer and perhaps one or two times in the winter.  Some meet up to four times a year but for longer sessions.

Many of us in the applied professions (social work, community economic  development, urban planning, etc.) fell into academia.  Some of us did not have our hearts set on teaching and research.  We therefore did not follow the traditional PhD route as one sees in the humanities and arts.  Some social sciences PhD students (political science, sociology, economics) also follow a traditional PhD program and therefore these disciplines do not consider people who are not “traditional students”  and have families who decide to pursue academia later on their careers.

Here are some personal pros for hybrid programs:

  1. Keep your job.  Well – can I say more? Medical Insurance and food on the table is important.
  2. Improve your teaching.  I find that I am a better teacher because of the research and theory classes.  In addition, working on my dissertation has made me read on a broad scale.  Because of my PhD involves a number of disciplines (development, economics, sociology, planning, social work, etc.)  I am able to see problems from an inter-disciplinary perspective.  My theory classes has given me a deeper foundation which can help to promote deep learning in the classroom.  I now can draw from the grand and middle range theories which permit me to help students to make connections between practice and theory.  I also find that I use Powerpoint less – chalkboard flow charts and mind maps are becoming a major staple in my classes.
  3. Engage with people who are practitioners in the field.  I am the only full-time academic in my program.  My fellow PhD slaves are involved local government, international development, nursing and public health.  (This wide range of backgrounds is also due to the nature of community economic development).  Because people are not full-time students and are not in their mid-20s, students have a different level of investment and perspective on their dissertation.  This is also a con – see later.

Cons:

  1. Lack of “academic community”.  Because people have many other things that they are trying to juggle, you might not experience the ongoing comradeship and community that traditional PhD students might experience.  This, of course, may not be always the case but support from fellow PhD travelers is so important as you run the marathon.
  2. Lack of research assistantships.  Depending on how the program is organized, there may be limited to no research assistantships possibilities for you.
  3. Lack of funding.  Because students are not studying full-time they do not have access to research assistantships which allow them to work with professors in the school.  This means that the external funding that this research provides for doctoral programs is missing or not a possibility because students live far from campus.
  4. Tuition. Many traditional program pay your tuition – this is not always the case for hybrid programs.
  5. Prestige. If you are looking to teach at a Research 1 institution once you have your degree make sure that you do your homework before choosing an hybrid program.  I still think Research 1 institutions do not look kindly on non-traditional PhD programs because at times these programs are less known.

I will post of list of hybrid social work, nonprofit management and public administration PhD programs soon.  Stay tuned.   Comments are welcome!

From Poverty to Power by Duncan Green » Blog Archive » Which governments are best/worst at ending hunger?

PND – RFPs Echoing Green Opens Application Period for Social Entrepreneur Fellowships

Recent speech by the CDFI Director speech

Here is a recent speech by CDFI Director Donna Gambrell at the Association for Enterprise Opportunity’s summit on May 18, 2009:

May 18, 2009

Introduction

Thank you for that kind introduction, Connie. It is an honor to be here today. Since I was appointed as Director of the Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFI) Fund 18 months ago, I have had the opportunity to address many such gatherings, but this is my first appearance at a national conference sponsored by the Association for Enterprise Opportunity (AEO). I thank you for the invitation.

The CDFI Fund’s purpose is to promote economic revitalization and community development through investment in and assistance to community development financial institutions � or CDFIs. We have the critical mission of expanding the capacity of these institutions to provide credit, capital, and financial services to underserved populations and economically distressed communities in the United States.

In Washington, we have seen some significant changes over the last six months, with the election of President Obama and the installation of his new Administration. AEO has seen change as well, with the appointment of Connie Evans as your new President and CEO. Connie brings more than 20 years of microenterprise experience to the position, is one of your earliest members, and was appointed by former President Clinton to serve on the very first Advisory Board of the CDFI Fund.

At a time when the microenterprise industry and the CDFI industry as a whole are in a position to play a very real and important part in America’s economic recovery, it is encouraging to know that you have a strong leader at your helm. Connie, thank you for taking on such an important responsibility. I look forward to closely working with you and AEO.

This year’s theme of Microenterprise: Restructuring Business as We Know It, resonates with me personally and could not be more timely or appropriate given the financial crisis that our country currently faces.

The CDFI Fund’s mission is very similar to that of the microfinance industry. We both support the entrepreneurial spirit that has always been at the heart of economic prosperity in America. We both aim to better low-income communities through investment, and I can’t think of a more important time in recent memory to renew ourselves to that shared goal.

To that end, I not only encourage you to utilize our programs, but more importantly, for us to work together and discuss ways the CDFI Fund can better help the microenterprise industry. Let us commit ourselves today to work on this together, because there is no better time than right now.

State of the CDFI Industry

The new Administration views the CDFI Fund with a renewed sense of responsibility. Let me share a few examples how.

The President has included the CDFI Fund in his strategy to address the current economic crisis. To that end, the Administration has assisted our mission through several important means.

First, one need look no further than the administration’s newly released 2010 budget to see for themselves. Entitled A New Era of Responsibility � Renewing America’s Promise, the budget more than doubles the CDFI Fund’s current operating budget of $107 million this year to $243.6 million for 2010 (an increase of 127 percent). This funding will go a long way in our efforts to assist the microfinance industry, and we appreciate the Administration’s understanding and respect for our mission and for the work that we do.

The budget requests also calls for $113.6 million for the CDFI Program, which represents a 90 percent increase. It also requests $80 million for the Capital Magnet Fund, a newly authorized program to increase capital investment for the development, preservation, rehabilitation, or the purchase of affordable housing for low-, very low-, and extremely low-income families.

It is also the first Administration budget to specifically include funding ($10 million) for the CDFI Fund’s Native Initiatives, which assist Native Communities (Native American, Alaskan Native and Native Hawaiian communities) to overcome certain barriers to financial services;

This funding will go a long way in helping those communities historically underserved by more traditional financial institutions. The CDFI Fund is committed to making the FY 2009 and FY 2010 awards as expeditiously as possible. This is a commitment I first made last year, and since then, the results speak louder than my words.

Just six weeks ago, the CDFI Fund announced 27 awards under the FY 2009 round of the CDFI Program’s Technical Assistance-Only program. Due to new business process efficiencies that have recently been implemented, these awards were made five months earlier than the same award announcement in FY 2008.

Since the announcement on March 26, 21 of the awards have been fully disbursed for more than $1.8 million. This is an astonishing 77 percent of the total TA awards of $2.3 million. Clearly, we are on the right track and the staff at the CDFI Fund is hard at work.

The CDFI Fund also received resources through the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (the Recovery Act). It provides us with an additional $3 billion of New Markets Tax Credit allocation authority, which will be awarded equally between fiscal year 2008 and fiscal year 2009.

In addition to the CDFI Fund’s annual appropriation for fiscal year 2009, the Recovery Act also appropriates an additional $100 million. $90 million of this total will be applied to the CDFI Program, $8 million will be used to fund Native Initiatives, and the final $2 million will be used to cover administrative expenses.

The CDFI Fund is moving expeditiously to award and disburse these Recovery Act resources. Later this month, we will announce $1.5 billion in allocation authority through our New Markets Tax Credit Program. In June, we will have announced the entire $98 million of Financial Assistance awards made available through the CDFI Program and Native American CDFI Assistance (NACA) Program.

In addition, the CDFI Fund has recently opened supplemental rounds for our grant programs in response to the growing demand and additional funding made available. I would encourage all certified CDFIs to take advantage of this while there is still time left for you to apply.

This is certainly a new day for the CDFI industry. Let us not waste this opportunity. Let us work together to demonstrate to all the vital role we play in providing responsible and affordable financial options for the low-income communities and residents we serve.

Data on Microenterprise Development

I would now like to focus on the area of microenterprise development and highlight some of our data which demonstrate just how active CDFIs are in the microenterprise field. Of all business loans made by CDFIs, over two-thirds (68.1 percent) are micro-loans, and nearly all of these micro-loans are fixed-interest loans (94.6 percent) and are fully amortized (91.1 percent).

  • The average size of micro-loans is $12,463, and the median is $10,000.
  • The average term is 54 months, and the median is 42 months.

These loans have supported businesses owned by both minorities and by women in both urban and rural areas, those who have had trouble acquiring them through more traditional lenders. Approximately 55 percent of these loans go to minority-owned or controlled businesses. Additionally, almost 43.7 percent of these loans go to women-owned or controlled businesses. I can also report that nearly half of these (44.4 percent) are to low-income controlled or owned businesses.

As a result of our increased funding, we are now in a much better position to support CDFIs that are committed to supporting microfinance in our nation’s low-income communities. Together through these efforts, we will create job lending and better practices, which are needed now more than ever as we deal with the financial crisis.

Case Studies

An example of a CDFI using a CDFI Program award to support more microenterprise development is the New Mexico Community Development Loan Fund, a private, tax-exempt organization. Its mission is to provide loans, training and business consulting to non-profit organizations and entrepreneurs within all areas of the Navajo Nation, throughout the United States.

Since 1989, the Loan Fund has provided services to support the efforts of low-income communities, in order to help them achieve their dreams of financial self-reliance. It has successfully assisted hundreds of small business owners and non-profit organizations over the past 20 years.

The businesses it partners with have a vested interest in community development. A prime example is Small World Day Care, which was created in response to the needs of low-income workers who needed a facility to look after their children during working hours. The center was opened in 1998, but within four years it had proven itself to be so popular that organizers realized more space was required. The Loan Fund took up their cause and helped them purchase a new building. Today, Small World cares for more than 40 children.

A relatively new microenterprise development organization supported by the CDFI Fund is the African Development Center (ADC). Created in Minneapolis in 2005, the ADC is a certified CDFI that provides training to African immigrant and refugee businesses, those that may not be applicable for more traditional sources of financing.

ADC is often seen as an industry of one, as there are very few organizations that provide the same service. Since their creation, ADC has lent more than $2 million to more than 130 businesses. Over the next three years, it predicts an annual growth rate of 15 percent.

Minnesota boasts a higher than normal immigration rate from African nations. According to the most recent U.S. Census statistics (2000), 13 percent of the state’s foreign born residents come from Africa, and this number is expected to increase dramatically by 2010. Minnesota offers immigrants an established African population, a strong economy, a good quality of life, educational opportunities, and unskilled jobs that don’t require fluency or literacy in English. These factors more than any other have helped make it an ideal refuge for many who have known nothing but war and poverty for most of their lives.

Certification

These are just two examples of the many microenterprise development projects that the CDFI Fund has supported. They illustrate our commitment to you and your communities, so I want to once again encourage all of you here today to utilize our award programs.

To those of you today who have already been a certified CDFI, as our funding increases, we want to support your work even more and we encourage you to make the most of it. The CDFI Fund is committed to your success, and we welcome the opportunity to work with you to achieve that.

To those of you who have not sought certification, now is the perfect time to do so, as the new Administration has thrown its support behind the CDFI Fund. The Recovery Act and the 2010 budget have greatly aided our ability to serve you.

Conclusion

It’s an exciting time for the CDFI Fund. With a renewed sense of purpose comes a greater ability and responsibility to serve community development organizations and the microenterprise industry. We have earned political capital, and it is up to all of us to see that it’s spent wisely. I appreciate AEO and all of its members, without whom we would not have the same impact in improving the lives and economic conditions within America’s neediest communities. We will do great things together.

Thank you for inviting me here today. We look forward to fostering new relationships and bringing your economic success stories to fruition.

Reading List on Corporate Social Responsibility

I am in the process of writing a paper on corporare social responsibility.  I’ve been rushing around borrowing books through ILL because I’m too cheap to buy them.  Thought I would share some of the “gems” with you.  Warning – reading these books over Christmas vacation may label you as a nerd.  Enter this knowledge at your own risk.

The Debate over Corporate Social Responsibility

When Principles Pay: Corporate Social Responsibility and the Bottom Line

Corporate Social Responsibility and International Development

Beyond Growth:  The Economics of Sustainable Development

The Market for Virtue: The Potential and Limits of Corporate Social Responsibility

Out of all of these, I have found the Market For Virtue and Principles that Pay most grounded in research.  While Hopkins’ book in corporate social responsibility and international development  is an interesting read, some of his claims on corporate social responsibility are not supported by a review of the literature especially concerning the relationship between corporate ethics and profits which show negative to neutral relationship between these two variables.

Another resource:  If you are looking to collect bibliographies in an easy way – make sure that you use WorldCat.  I collect a variety of books on various issues on WorldCat, which I have made public in case you are looking for books on international development, corporate social responsibility, and community economic development.  You can go to WorldCat and search for rkfernando.

Some new blogs to watch

Bread Blog – Bread for the World’s blog on hunger and development issues

Blog for Debt – Jubilee USA blog on international debt and debt forgiveness

Blog for Rural America -  Center for Rural America’s blog

Global Development Matters – The Center for Global Development blog

Please make sure to check out my blog clearinghouse just to the right of this post on the various blog clearinghouse pages.

just got this fun video from my wife…enjoy!

My whole day: Tear Fund

more about "My whole day: Tear Fund", posted with vodpod

Forces for Good

I am almost done with an excellent nonprofit management book, Forces for Good: The Six Practices of High-Impact Nonprofits. The book is written by Leslie Crutchfield and Heather McLeod Grant. I’ve read a number of nonprofit and management books in the last few years, but this book is to me, one of the best out there. The writers examine the common practices of 12 high-impact nonprofits:. Share our Strength, YouthBuild, Self-Help Credit Union, and Habitat for Humanity are some of the organizations examined in the book. I would also say that they way each chapter is organized is also easy for the reader to refer back to the book on a later date for research or to incorporate some of the principles in one’s own nonprofit.

Below is audio and video resources where the Heather talks about the book and its implications for the social sector. Happy Reading!

What Makes Great Nonprofits Great?

Course at the Chalmers Center

The Chalmers Center for Economic Development will offer their “Foundations and Principles of Holistic Ministry” distance learning course twice this fall. The first offering is scheduled for August 18 – September 13, 2008 and the second for October 20 – November 15, 2008. The fall offering of the follow up course, “Principles and Practices of Christian Microfinance and Microenterprise Development,” has one remaining seat; however, it will be offered again in Spring 2009. fall-foundations-announcement

Older entries »